|
|
Disease or Infection |
Total |
Tanks |
Netpens |
Fresh caught |
|
Exophthalmia* |
35/128(27) |
10/47(21) |
25/70(36) |
0/11 |
|
Swim bladder inflammation* |
23/128 (18) |
13/47(28) |
10/70(14) |
0/11 |
|
Cyst of unknown origins |
2/143 (1) |
0/62 |
1/70 (1) |
1/11(9) |
|
Epitheliocystis |
1/43 (1) |
1/62 (2) |
0/70 |
0/11 |
|
Goussia (surface type) |
6/143 (5) |
3/62(5) |
3/70(4) |
0/11 |
|
Cryptocaryon irritans |
35/143 (24) |
35/62(56) |
0/70 |
0/11 |
|
IchthyophonusÝ |
4/143(3) |
3/62(5) |
1/70(1) |
0/11 |
|
Didymozoid digenean |
31/143 (22) |
9/62(14) |
15/70(21) |
7/11(64) |
|
Monogenea (e.g., Diplectanum)* |
11/128(9) |
8/47(17) |
3/70 (4) |
0/11 |
|
Caligid Copepods* |
34/128(27) |
34/47(72) |
0/70 |
0/11 |
|
Encysted helminthes ý |
44/143(31) |
21/62(34) |
16/70(23) |
7/11(64) |
Swim
bladder Infections and Inflammation. Several
moribund fish exhibited septic swim bladders. At necropsy,
the swim bladder wall was opaque, and the swim bladder often
contained an opaque, viscous to caseous, whitish or yellow
exudate (Fig. 1). Histologically, the lesions were
characterized by severe, chronic inflammation (Fig. 2). Figure 1. Swim
bladder inflammation and bacterial infections. A.
Intact swim bladder before dissection. Note that
the swim bladder wall is opaque. B. Dissected swim
bladder revealing yellow, caseous exudate
(E). Fig.
2. Low magnification of swim bladder showing severe
chronic inflammation. Fig
3. Masses of bacteria and associated chronic
inflammation in swim bladder. Masses of presumptive
Gram-negative bacilli were observed in most
lesions, and one fish exhibited a fungal infection
of the swim bladder (Fig 4). Two fish exhibited
intracellular cocci in macrophages in these lesions
suggestive of Piscirickettsia. Further tests
are underway to verify the identity of this
putative rickettsia-like infection.
Piscirickettsia salmonis and related
organisms have caused severe disease in aquaculture
species, including pen-reared salmon, white sea
bass, and tilapia (Fryer and Lannan 1996).
Infections of the swim bladder were likely due to
iatrogenic causes - i.e., associated with
introduction of contaminated hypodermic needles
during de-gassing of swim bladders immediately
after capture or due to a tract from the skin
surface being created by the needle, and thus
allowing bacteria to infect the swim
bladder. Considering the severity of
the swim bladder bacterial infections, it was
remarkable that this did not progress to
septicemia. Based on our experiences, such
progression would be expected with similar
infections in other fish species. This suggests
that opakapaka held in captivity have a very
competent immune system, which is capable of
containing severe infections. Fig 4.
Intracellular piscirickettsia-like organisms
(arrows) in macrophages. Fig 5. Fungus
infection of swim bladder. A. low magnification
showing granulomas (G). B. Fungal hyphae in
lesion. Figure 6.
Opakapaka with bilateral exophthalmia. A. Note
bulging eyes. B, C. Histological sections of eyes.
B. Gas bubbles (B) within hemorrhage (H) and
chronic inflammation (I) in retrobulbar vascular
plexus. C. Chronic inflammation with multinucleate
giant cells (arrows) and eosinophilic granule cells
in eye with panophthalmitis. Eye
Lesions. Many fish
exhibited eye lesions, generally characterized by
exophthalmia (pop-eye), with gas bubbles in or
around the eye (Fig 6). Representative samples were
evaluated by histology. Eyes are very difficult to
process for histology, and thus notations on eye
lesions do not occur for every fish with
macroscopic eye damage (Table
1). In general, the eyes exhibited gas bubbles
(emphysema) and hemorrhage in the retrobulbar
vascular plexus (Fig. 6). Many of these eyes
subsequently developed chronic inflammatory
lesions. As with the swim bladder
lesions, the underlying cause is probably
iatrogenic - i.e., due to gas bubble disease
induced by transporting the fish to the surface
after capture in deep waters. However, spontaneous
exophthalmia associated with gas bubbles in the
eyes was recently reported in the West Australian
dhufish (Glaucosoma hebraicum) that were
reared from birth in captivity as well as in
wild-caught fish (Stephens et al. 2001). Moreover,
we have seen an identical condition in ling cod
(Ophidon elongatus) that were hatched in
captivity. Stephens et al. (2001) concluded that
the likely cause of the lesions in captive-reared
dhufish (and some other deep water marine fishes)
was a reduced ability to adapt to rapid changes in
activity patterns or water quality differences,
even if hatched in captivity. For opakapaka,
rearing fish in surface water netpens or tanks
would represent a situation with lower water
pressure and warmer water temperature than their
normal environment. Figure 7.
Epitheliocystis, caused by a chlamydia-like
microorganism, in the gill of
opakapaka. Figure 8
(right). Ichthyophonus in opakapaka. A.
Inflammation and fibroplasia around intact organism
(arrows). Note fungus-like appearance of parasite.
B. Possible degenerated organism (arrow) in
lesion. Epitheliocystis.
One fish exhibited a lesion consistent with
infection by epitheliocystis, a chlamydia-like
infection (Fig. 7). Epitheliocystis is common in
wild marine fishes, and has occasionally caused
disease in aquaculture (Lannan et al. 1999). The
disease is particularly problematic in cultured
bream (Sparus aurata) (cf. Paperna 1977) and
sea bass (Dicentrachus labrax) (cf. Crespo
et al. 2001). Ichthyophonus.
One fish exhibited infection by Ichthyophonus sp.
(Fig. 8). In addition, three other exhibited
degenerative lesions that we suspect were resolved
Ichthyophonus infections. This protistan parasite
is a common in wild marine fishes and occasionally
is problematic in fish culture (McVicar 1999).
Previously the parasite has been considered a
fungus, but molecular systematics suggest that it
is related to the choanoflagellates (including
Dermocystidium and the rosette agent of
salmon). The life cycle is direct, and fish can
contract the infection by water-borne spores, or
feeding on infected fish and crustaceans. The
infection is cosmopolitan, and has been reported
from cold and warm water marine fishes. The lesions
were minor in opakapaka, but this infection should
be monitored, as it is has the potential to spread
in culture situations and can be highly
pathogenic. Cryptocaryon
irritans. Gill
infections associated with prominent epithelial
hyperplasia were observed in moribund fish held in
tanks (Fig. 9). This ciliate is a well-recognized
and serious pathogen of warm water marine
aquaculture and aquaria (Dickerson and Dawe 1999).
It is difficult to treat with routine bath
chemotherapeutics as it has an off-host stage and
the on-host stage (trophont) embeds under the skin
and gill epithelium (Fig. 9). Moreover, the use of
external baths to treat parasites in large,
extensive aquaculture operations, such as netpens,
is usually impractical due to costs and problems
associated with environmental contamination. This
ciliate already is clearly recognized as a
potential cause of high mortalities in tank-held
opakapaka at Coconut Island. Interestingly,
infections in netpen-held opakapaka appear to be
absent (Table 1), possibly due to flushing of the
off-host stages of the parasite from the pens and
relatively low density of fish in netpens compared
to tanks. Many fish from tanks
exhibited early Cryptocaryon infections in
which the parasite was present but was not
associated with significant pathological changes.
However, moribund fish from the group held in tanks
showed lesions consistent with the disease - e.g.,
severe, diffuse epithelial hyperplasia of the gills
(Fig. 9). One of us (A. Moriwake)
conducted treatment experiments (Table 2), and
found that transferring fish to a new tank every 3
days for 3 cycles was effective for controlling
infections. Figure 9
(right). Gill infected with Cryptocaryon.
A.Wet mount. Note that the parasite occurs under
the epithelium. B. Histological section showing
severe epithelial hyperplasia associated with
parasites (arrows).









Four parasites were found on the gills and skin of captive
opakapaka. This included a Caligus sp. and two types
of trematodes on newly caught fish, and a
Cryptocaryon sp. ("marine ich") occurring repeatedly
in the hatchery. Several experiments were conducted to
control or eliminate parasites. Three to four individuals
were used in each experiment. All fish were examined for
parasites prior to treatment and 3 days after treatment with
the exception of the last two experiments in which fish were
examined every 3 days for 3 cycles. Fish that died during
the course of the experiment were examined upon
death.

Table 2. Treatment
Protocols to Control External Parasites on Juvenile
Opakapaka (Prepared by Aaron
Moriwake)
(Summary of trials conducted on opakapaka for parasite
treatment)
Parasite Treatment
Duration Effective
Survival
Day 1
(%) Survival
Day
3 (%) Caligus Formalin 25 ppm 60 minutes YES 100 100 Caligus Formalin 50 ppm 60 minutes YES 100 100 Caligus Formalin 75 ppm 30 minutes YES 100 33 Caligus Formalin 100 ppm 15 minutes YES 100 100 Caligus Freshwater bath 5 minutes YES 100 100 Monogeneans Formalin 200 ppm 15 minutes NO 100 100 Monogeneans Formalin 740 ppm 5 minutes NO 67 * Monogeneans Formalin 740 ppm 5 minutes NO 67 * Monogeneans Freshwater bath 15 minutes NO 100 75 Monogeneans Freshwater bath 10 minutes NO 100 100 Cryptocaryon
H202
150 ppm 30 minutes NO 67 0 Cryptocaryon H202
150 ppm 15 minutes NO 67 0 Cryptocaryon Formalin 250 ppm 10 minutes NO 100 80 Cryptocaryon Freshwater bath 3 day cycle
5 minutes YES 100 100 Cryptocaryon Transfer 3 day
cycle YES 100 100
* Fish were sacrificed
for microscopic examination.
Goussia
spp. (Coccidia).
We observed a coccidian species, most likely a
Goussia sp., infecting the brush boarder of
the intestinal epithelium. Many fish were infected,
with two moribund fish showing severe infections
(Fig 10). Fish with heavy infections exhibited
enteritis and atrophy of the infected epithelium.
The gut epithelium is a primary site of infection
by coccidia, including those infecting fish
(Molnár 1999). Infections at the surface of
epithelial cells, as seen here, are similar to
Cryptospordium infections of mammals, and
this type of Goussia infections in fish may
likewise be pathogenic. For example, Goussia
(=Epieimeria) anguillae is a pathogen of eels
(Lacey and Williams 1983), and we described chronic
mortality associated with a wasting syndrome in
opaleye (Girella nigricans) due to G.
girellae held at the Scripps Aquarium, San
Diego (Kent et al. 1988). Therefore, this infection
in opakapaka should be considered as a potential
problem in the future and should be
monitored. A second Goussia sp.
was observed in one fish (Fig 10B). In this case,
the organism developed deep within the epithelium
and occasionally in the lamina propria. Also in
contrast to the other Goussia species from
opakapaka, sporulated oocysts were frequently
observed. Although a different species, the
infection and pathogenic changes were suggestive of
Goussia carpelli infections in carp and
goldfish. In this infection, "yellow bodies" are
formed around the oocysts and the parasite causes
atrophy of the gut and a wasting syndrome (Kent and
Hedrick 1985). Fig. 10 (right).
Coccidians in opakapaka. A. Intestinal
epithelium-surface type found in many fish. B. A
second species occurred deep within the epithelium
and lamina propria. Arrow = three sporulated
oocysts in the epithelium. Monogenea.
Gill and skin
infections by monogenea worms are well-recognized
problems in marine and freshwater fishes held in
captivity. Two species of monogenea were observed;
Diplectanum opakapaka (Fig. 11A) and
Pseudodiscocotyla opakapaka (Fig. 11B).
Infections by both monogeneans in the present study
were light and not associated with significant gill
lesions. Another Diplectanum species, D.
latesi, has caused mortality in captive sea
bass (Lates calcarifer) (cf. Rajendran et
al. 2000). Monogeneans can usually be easily
eradicated with baths containing formalin or
organophosphates, but the use of these compounds in
netpens or other large-scale operations may be
impractical. Furthermore, we have found formalin to
be ineffective for treating these infections on
opakapaka (Table 2). We found the best way to
control large monogeneans (presumably members of
the family Capsalidae) on the skin was to pick them
off individually using forceps. A treatment of 15
minutes in freshwater appear to be close to the
maximum amount of time the fish can survive in
freshwater.

Figure 11.
Monogeneans from the gills of opakapaka. A. Diplectanum
opakapaka.

B. Pseudodiscocotyla opakapaka. 0 = opisthaptor
(posterior attachment organ).
Digenea.
Trematodes of the family Didymozoidae are unusual
digeneans in that the adult stages are
extraintestinal in marine fishes (whereas most
other adult digeneans occur in the gut lumen). A
large (up to about 100 mm), elongate worm
superficially resembling a nematode was often
observed in the gill chamber, heart, or near the
anterior kidney (Fig 12). We identified the worm as
Metanematobothrioides opakapaka.
Histological sections of the infected tissue
revealed little tissue reaction. The most severe
lesion was moderate, chronic epicarditis of the
heart in one fish (Fig 12B). Furthermore, as these
worms require an intermediate host and do not
replicate in fish, they will not likely be serious
problems in the culture of opakapaka. Figure 12.
Didymozoid digenean trematode
Metanematobothrioides opakapaka from
visceral organs. A. Whole worm dissected from
tissues. B. Histological sections of worms in
pericardium of heart. Arrow = inflammation
surrounding worms (D). C. Cross sections of worms
(D) in viscera near kidney.


Cestodes. Larval cestodes were observed in the intestinal lumen of some fish, and were not associated with severe pathological changes (Fig 13).
Figure 13. Larval cestode in intestine of opakapaka. Infections were associated with little tissue damage. G = coccidium.
Copepods.
Two types of copepods
were observed; a Caligus sp. (Fig 14A),
which moves freely on the skin, and an attached
lernaeopodid (a member of the family
Lernaeopodidae) (Fig 14B). The latter was observed
on a wild-caught fish. Photographs of the
lernaeopodid were shown to Dr. Z. Kabata, Pacific
Biological Station, Nanaimo, British Columbia (the
world's foremost authority on parasitic copepods)
and he stated that these specimens likely represent
a new genus. Caligid copepods can be extremely
problematic in netpen culture - i.e.,
Lepeophtheirus salmonis is one of the most
important problems caused by infectious agents in
the netpen farming of salmonids in Europe (Boxshall
and DeFaye 1993). Dr Z. Kabata also examined the
caligids, and the following is from a pers. comm.
that suggests that these specimens may represent a
new species. The use of both formalin
(between 25 - 100 ppm) and freshwater bath were
effective in eliminating Caligus (Table 2).
Fish appear to be stressed (head bobbing out of the
water) at the higher doses (75 and 100 ppm) of
formalin. After one minute in the freshwater bath,
no parasites were observed on the fish. Figure 14.
Copepods from opakapaka. A. Caligus sp., a
common infection in captive fish. B. Lerneopodid
copepod from wild-caught opakapaka. Arrows = egg
sacs at posterior end of female
copepods Fig. 15.
Encysted parasites, etc. A. Metacercaria in kidney.
B. Melanized granuloma. Granulomas
and Encysted Helminthes. Encysted
metacercariae of trematodes were occasionally
observed in tissue sections (Fig. 15A). In
addition, many granulomas contained debris, which
may represent degenerated parasites were observed
(Fig 15B). These represent the whitish nodules seen
in the mesenteries or around the liver at necropsy.
As the contents of the cysts were very degenerated
(encapsulated spheres with necrotic centers),
specific identifications were not possible. They
likely represent the metacercariae, and will
probably not be a concern in the culture of this
fish. Both wild and captive fish exhibited these
lesions (Table 1), and they can be considered
merely normal "background" infections of wild fish.
A few fish exhibited granulomas more suggestive of
Mycobacterium infections (fish
tuberculosis), but acid-fast stains of these
lesions did not reveal bacteria. Fatty
Liver Disease. Hepatic
lipodosis (fatty livers) was observed in several of
the fish from diet studies. Figure 16 contrasts
normal with fatty livers. The long-term effects of
this condition are unknown, but this change is
usually reversible. It is likely that these liver
changes were due to inappropriate diets. It should
be noted that most of the fish with fatty livers
came from diet studies. Cysts of
Unknown Origin. These
enigmatic structures (Fig. 17), also referred to as
"unidentified fish objects" or "UFO's" are rather
common in marine fishes (MacLean et al. 1987). We
observed these in the gills of one fish and the
kidney of another. They generally are associated
only with local tissue reactions, including
prominent cartilage metaplasia (Heidel et al.
2001). Some researchers have proposed that these
might represent ectopic eggs, but they have also
been observed in male fish. Therefore, at present,
the consensus of most researchers is that they are
degenerated microorganisms of unknown
identity. This study confirmed previous
observations of aquaculturists that Cryptocaryon
irritans may be a serious pathogen of
opakapaka. Other parasites such as the coccidians
(Goussia spp.), the monogeneans and the
copepods should be monitored as related species are
already recognized as causes of disease in marine
aquaculture. These parasites are monoxenous (one
host) parasites and thus may proliferate in or on
fish in captivity. Interestingly, the external
parasites (Cryptocaryon, monogeneans and
copepods) were much more prevalent in fish held in
tanks, suggesting that the netpen environment was
more favorable for avoiding proliferation of these
potential pathogens in captive fish. Figure 17. Cyst
of unknown origin surrounded by metaplastic
cartilage [C] in kidney.
"I have examined
closely your specimens of Caligus from
Hawaii. The closest I can come up with is
Caligus brevis Shiino, 1954 and C.
oviceps Shiino, 1952(these two are
distinguishable with some difficulty). However,
both of them differ from your specimens in the
shape of the sternal furca. This is the only
significant difference I could find.
Unfortunately, Shiino's descriptions lack
adequate detail to make any definite differences
meaningful. The hosts are quite unrelated, too.
(Another record of C.brevis, from New
Zealand, is incorrect, it deals with a species
distinct from C.brevis). Under the
circumstances there is a possibility that it is
a new species. The only way to clinch it is to
check the type material of brevis, which
is in Japan in custody of Kunihiko
Izawa."


Fig.
16. Opakapaka livers. A. fatty liver, note
hepatocytes filled with clear vacuoles representing
fat. B. normal liver.
Conclusion

Bacterial infections and associated inflammatory changes in the swim bladder were very likely the result of the practice of de-gassing captured fish by insertion of a hypodermic needle into the swim bladder, and thus at this point would be considered as only opportunists.
Likewise, exophthalmia was consistently associated with gas emboli in the eyes, again probably associated with collecting procedures. However, other causes should be considered if this condition arises in captive-reared fish. Blood smears and kidney imprints were for the most part not informative, but they did confirm that fish fish did have exhibit septicemia or obvious blood parasites.
Further studies should entail continued routine diagnostics of moribund and dead fish. Cryptocaryon is already recognized as a health problem with this and other marine fishes held in captivity, and we recommend research on the control of this pathogen. Considering the difficulties with the use of external baths in netpens, we suggest that a long-term solution may be the development of a vaccine for this ciliate parasite. This approach shows promise as significant success for the development of a vaccine has been achieved for Ichthyophthirius multifiliis (Clark and Dickerson 1997), Cryptocaryon's freshwater cousin. Moreover, as with Ich, it is already recognized that fish that have recovered from Cryptocaryon infections exhibit resistance to reinfection (Dickerson and Dawe 1999).
Although we have not identified viral diseases in opakapaka to date, it is likely that some viral diseases will afflict this species as culture of this fish moves forward. Therefore, another area of research would be the development of specific cell lines from opakapaka and related fishes. Many fish viruses require rather specific cell lines, and thus have only been isolated using cell lines derived from the host species. Last, it would be worthwhile to describe the coccidians as they may cause problems in the future in this host or related fish species.
Acknowledgement. The Hawaii Sea Grant Program Development supported this study and Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resources, Division of Aquatic Resources. We thank Dr. Whitlow Au for assistance with administration of the grant.
Boxshall, G.A., and D. DeFaye. [eds.]. 1993. Aspects of the behaviour of copepodid larvae of the salmon louse Lepeophtheirus salmonis (Koryer, 1837). Pathogens of Wild and Farmed Fish: Sea Lice. Ellis Horwood, Chichester, England.
Clark, T.G., and H.W. Dickerson. 1997. Antibody-mediated effects on parasite behavior: Evidence of a novel mechanism of immunity against a parasitic protist. Parasitol. Today 13(12):477-480.
Crespo, S., S. Zarza, and F. Padrós. 2001. Epitheliocystis hyperinfection in sea bass, Dicentrachus labrax (L.): light and electron microscope observations. J. Fish Dis. 24:551-560.
Ganzhorn, J. and S.E. LaPatra. 1994. General Procedures for Virology. In Suggested Procedures for the Detection and Identification of Certain Finfish and Shellfish Pathogens. Blue Book 4th Edition. (ed. J. Thoesen) Fish Health Section, American Fisheries Society.
Dickerson, H.W. and D.L. Dawe. 1999. Ichthyophthirius multifiliis and Cryptocaryon irritans. In Fish Diseases and Disorders Vol 1. Protozoan and Metazoan Infections. (ed. By P.T.K. Woo). CABI Publ. CAB International, Wallingford, Oxon, England. pp. 181-227.
Fryer, J.L., and C.N. Lannan. 1996. Rickettsial infections in fish. Ann. Rev. Fish. Dis 6:3-13.
Kent, M.L., Fournie, J.W. Snodgrass, R.E., and R.A. Elston. 1988. Goussia girellae n. sp. (Apicomplexa: Eimeriorina) in the opaleye Girella nigricans. J. Protozool. 35:287-290.
Kent, M.L., and R.P. Hedrick. 1985. The biology and associated pathology of Goussia carpelli (Léger and Stankovitch) in goldfish Carassius auratus (L.). Fish Pathol. 20:485-494.
Heidel, J.R., B. Nowak, K. Fischer, V. Watral, S. C. Dawe, S.M. Jones, and M.L. Kent. 2001. Visceral nodular cartilaginous metaplasia in rockfishes (Sebastes spp.) in the eastern North Pacific Ocean. J. Vet. Diag. Methods (in press).
Lacey, S.M., and I.C. Williams. 1983. Epieimeria anguillae (Lleger & Hollande, 1922) Dyková & Lom, 1981 (Apicomplexa: Eucoccidia) in the European eel, Anguilla anguilla (L.). J. Fish Biol. 23:605-609.
Lannan, C.N., J.L. Bartholomew, and J.L. Fryer. 1999. Rickettsial and chlamydial infections. In: Fish Diseases and Disorders Vol. 3. Viral, Bacterial and Fungal Infections (ed. by P.T.K. Woo & D.W. Bruno), pp. 245-267. CAB Intl., London.
MacLean, S.A., C.M. Morrison, R.A. Murchelano, S. Everline, and J.J. Evans. 1987. Cysts of unknown etiology in marine fishes of the Northwest Atlantic and Gulf of Mexico. Can. J. Zool. 65:296-303.
McVicar, A.H. 1999. Ichthyophonus and related organisms. In: Fish Diseases and Disorders Vol. 3. Viral, Bacterial and Fungal Infections (ed. by P.T.K. Woo & D.W. Bruno), pp. 670-687. CAB Intl., London.
Molnár, K. 1999. Phylum Apicomplexa. In Fish Diseases and Disorders Vol 1. Protozoan and Metazoan Infections.(ed. by P.T.K. Woo). CABI Publ. CAB International, Wallingford, Oxon, England. pp. 263-288.
Paperna, I. 1977. Epitheliocystis infection in wild and cultured sea bream (Sparus aurata, Sparidae) and grey mullets (Liza ramanda, Mugilidae). Aquaculture 10:169-176.
Rajendran, K.V., A.R. Thirunavukkarasu and T.C. Santiago. 2000. Mortality of captive seabass, Lates calcarifer (Bloch) due to monogenetic parasite, Diplectanum latesi (Tripathi, 1957) J. Aquacult. Trop.15:199 -206.
Stephen, F.J., J.J. Clearly, G. Jenkins, B. Jones, S.R. Raidal, and J.B. Thomas. 2001. Pathogenesis and epidemiology of spontaneous exophthalmos in the West Australian dhufish, Glaucosoma hebraicum Richardson. J. Fish Dis. 24:515-522.
Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology
Hawaii Undersea Research Laboratory-Milestone Report
NURP Management Information System
Hawaii Undersea Research Laboratory-2nd Quarter Milestone Report
Updated August 15, 2002.